Skip to content

— Fraud and bots on Shopify · Guide

What to do when Shopify marks an order as high risk

Published 14 November 2026 · Last updated · Sources read 14 November 2026 · General information, not legal advice

Short answer

Open the order, read the fraud recommendation, and review a high-risk order before you fulfill it. Shopify warns that fulfilling high-risk orders can lead to more chargebacks, and that chargebacks can lead to the deactivation of payment processing and removal from Shopify Payments.[1]

What a high-risk order is on Shopify

Shopify's fraud analysis is there so you can spot orders that may be fraudulent and review them in your admin before you fulfill them. For eligible online credit card orders, the fraud recommendation says whether the order has a low, medium or high risk of a chargeback due to fraud.[1]

If an order has a medium or high risk, it is flagged on the Orders page with a warning symbol next to the order number. Flagged orders are also highlighted in order notification emails when you subscribe to those emails.[1]

Shopify is clear about why this review matters. Credit card companies can reverse funds for stolen cards after orders are fulfilled. You can gather evidence for disputed charges, but the decision to reverse funds is made by the bank that issued the card, not by Shopify, and Shopify does not cover those charge reversals.[1]

Which orders get a fraud analysis

Fraud analysis works with online credit card orders that Shopify can verify. Fraud indicators, and support for third-party fraud prevention apps, are available on the Basic plan or higher. Fraud recommendations are available on the Grow plan or higher, or when you use Shopify Payments.[1]

Some orders do not receive a fraud recommendation. Shopify lists test orders, free orders, orders paid in full with a gift card, Point of Sale orders, B2B orders, and subscription renewal orders. You can still simulate a fraud recommendation on a test order. If you use a third-party payment processor, Shopify says to check with them about any fraud analysis limitations.[1]

Shopify Payments can also block some high-risk checkout attempts before an order is created. Those attempts never become orders, so they have no fraud recommendation. You can review them in the Blocked view of Orders, under Abandoned checkouts. If you know the customer and still want the sale, Shopify says you can create a draft order and send an invoice.[1]

Read the recommendation, not one indicator

Fraud analysis has two parts. Indicators are individual details about the order. The recommendation is the overall risk level and the suggested next step. Shopify tells you to use the indicators to investigate, and to use the recommendation to judge overall risk.[1]

Indicators can describe address and payment checks, or patterns tied to the customer, location, device and network. They can include whether the card passed Address Verification System (AVS) checks, whether the customer gave the correct Card Verification Value (CVV), whether the customer's location matches the payment method, whether there is unusual device or network activity, and whether the customer tried to use more than one credit card. The available indicators can differ between orders.[1]

In the revised Order risk evaluation view for a Shopify assessment, indicators sit together in a shaded panel, with icons that mark details associated with fraudulent behaviour, legitimate behaviour, or neutral details. Other views, including mobile, may group items as high risk signals, low risk signals and other details, or use red, green and grey icons.[1]

An IP address, when available, is listed separately from the indicators. A location description can also appear as separate metadata. Shopify says an IP address or location description by itself is not a fraud recommendation. Location-related risk indicators, such as a mismatch between customer location and payment method, remain in the indicator list.[1]

The important rule is this: individual indicators and group headings do not represent the order's overall risk level. Do not decide to fulfill or cancel from one indicator, or from how many indicators you can count. Review the fraud recommendation instead. If the order also has Shopify Protect information, review that protection status separately from the indicators.[1]

What Shopify says to do next

Fraud recommendations are produced by machine learning trained on historical transactions across Shopify stores. Review both the risk level and the recommended next step. In the Order risk evaluation view, the guidance can be "You can fulfill this order", "Confirm with the customer before fulfilling", or "Consider canceling this order". That guidance follows the order's recommendation, not a single indicator.[1]

If an order is at a high risk of fraud, Shopify says you can attempt to verify the order, cancel the order, or refund the order. The point of the analysis is to let you do that review before fulfilment, because fulfilling high-risk orders can result in a higher number of chargebacks.[1]

  • Open the order and read the Order risk section on the order details page. Suspicious orders are flagged with an exclamation mark icon.[1]
  • Read the recommendation and the suggested next step first, then use the indicators to investigate.[1]
  • If the guidance is to confirm with the customer, contact them before you fulfill, and keep that conversation on the order.[1]
  • If the order is high risk and the pattern looks like fraud, cancel or refund rather than shipping first.[1]

Give yourself time before you capture payment

If you want time to investigate orders before you accept payment for them, Shopify says you can set up manual payment captures. That keeps the payment from being captured until you have looked at the risk recommendation.[1]

Manual capture is especially useful when you cannot review every order the moment it arrives. A high-risk order that is already captured and fulfilled is harder to unwind if the card later turns out to be stolen. Shopify notes that banks, not Shopify, decide charge reversals, and that Shopify does not cover those reversals.[1]

Agree internally who is allowed to fulfill a flagged order, and who can cancel one, so a high-risk order is not packed because it looked ordinary in the queue.

Good orders marked as high risk: what to do

A high-risk recommendation is a prediction, not a verdict. Real customers get flagged too, for example when the billing and shipping addresses differ or the card's address check fails. Shopify says that for a high-risk order you can attempt to verify it, cancel it or refund it, so contact the customer through the details on the order before you cancel a sale you may want.[1]

If you decide to ship, record why on the order. If a chargeback follows, that note and the customer's reply are part of the evidence you can gather for the dispute.[1]

Auto-hold or cancel high-risk orders with Flow

Shopify Flow can automate how you handle high-risk orders: for example, capture payment automatically for low and medium-risk orders, hold high-risk orders for manual review, or cancel and restock orders that meet criteria you set.[3] Holding is the safer default; automatic cancelling also cancels the good orders that were flagged by mistake.

Where a third-party fraud app fits

Shopify supports third-party fraud prevention apps on the Basic plan or higher. When an order has assessments from more than one provider, you select the provider whose assessment you want to review. The full analysis may be labelled Order risk evaluation or About this order, depending on the view.[1]

An app does not replace Shopify's recommendation. It can add its own reasons and a workflow so a risky order is not fulfilled while you are away from the admin. Estre, which we make, checks each new Shopify order, adds its reasons to the order, and can hold a high-risk order until you approve it (it ships) or block it (it is cancelled, refunded and restocked). You can start in Watch mode, which records what Estre would do without changing anything. Estre does not cancel an order unless you choose to. There is a free plan. See Estre on the Shopify App Store if you want that hold workflow.[2]

For chargebacks that still arrive after fulfilment, and for card-testing patterns that often sit behind a run of high-risk orders, see the guides on Shopify chargeback prevention and how to stop card testing on Shopify.

After you decide: fulfill, cancel or refund

If the recommendation says you can fulfill the order, and your own check of the indicators does not raise a fresh doubt, fulfill it as you would any other paid order. If the recommendation is to confirm with the customer, wait for a reply that a real buyer would be able to give, such as a detail about the order or the delivery address, before you ship.[1]

If you cancel or refund a high-risk order, do it before fulfilment whenever you can. Shipping first, then trying to recover the goods after a chargeback, is the situation Shopify is warning you about when it says stolen-card funds can be reversed after the order is fulfilled.[1]

Keep a short record on the order of what you checked and why you fulfilled, cancelled or refunded it. That note is for your own staff as much as for a later dispute: the next person who opens the order should be able to see the decision.

Questions

Should I cancel every order Shopify marks as high risk?
Not automatically. Shopify says that for a high-risk order you can attempt to verify it, cancel it, or refund it, and that the on-screen guidance may be to confirm with the customer before fulfilling, or to consider cancelling. Read the recommendation and then investigate.[1]
Why does a high-risk order have only one or two red indicators?
Individual indicators do not represent the overall risk level. Shopify tells you not to decide from one indicator, or from the number of indicators, and to use the fraud recommendation instead.[1]
Why does a test order or a gift-card order have no recommendation?
Some orders do not receive a fraud recommendation, including test orders, free orders, orders paid in full with a gift card, Point of Sale orders, B2B orders and subscription renewals. You can still simulate a recommendation on a test order.[1]
What can a fraud app do that Shopify's analysis does not?
Shopify already gives you indicators and, on eligible plans, a recommendation. A third-party app can add its own assessment and a hold so the order does not ship while you review it. Estre holds high-risk orders until you approve or block them, with its reasons on the order, and can be run in Watch mode first.[1][2]
Is this legal or payments advice?
No. This is practical guidance based on Shopify's fraud-analysis help and on how Estre works. Chargeback and payment rules depend on the card network and your payment provider.

Hold high-risk orders before they ship

Estre checks each new Shopify order as it arrives and can hold high-risk ones until you approve or block them, with its reasons on the order. There is a free plan, and Watch mode lets you see what it would do first.

Disclosure: Estre is made by Misimi Corp, which also makes Shaewoo and publishes this site.

Sources

Every fact in this guide links to one of these, read on 14 November 2026. Estre is named only where it is relevant; nothing here is a review, a rating or a promise about results.

  1. Shopify Help Center: Reviewing orders with fraud analysis
  2. Shopify App Store: Estre listing
  3. Shopify Help Center: Protecting orders from fraud