Skip to content

— Fraud and bots on Shopify · Guide

How to respond to a Shopify chargeback, and what evidence to submit

Published 19 November 2026 · Last updated · Sources read 19 November 2026 · General information, not legal advice

Short answer

When a chargeback opens, the disputed amount and a fee are withdrawn and Shopify gives you a deadline, usually 7–21 days. Before it, submit evidence that fits the dispute type: delivery proof for item not received, AVS, CVV and 3D Secure results for fraud, refund records for credit not processed. Shopify Payments adds order details automatically. The card company, not Shopify, decides, and the decision is final.[1][2]

First, check whether it is a chargeback or an inquiry

When a customer disputes a charge, their bank opens either a chargeback or an inquiry. On a chargeback, the disputed amount and the chargeback fee are withdrawn immediately. On an inquiry, no money is taken while the bank investigates, but an inquiry resolved in the customer's favour might escalate to a full chargeback.[2]

Both are answered the same way: you collect and submit evidence before the deadline Shopify gives you.[2] If you use Shopify Payments, the amount of a chargeback is deducted from your next available payout.[1]

Not every dispute can be answered. If your store is enrolled in a network dispute resolution program, disputes are resolved automatically, with funds reimbursed to customers before they become formal chargebacks, and there is no evidence-submission window.[1][2]

The chargeback timeline on Shopify

  1. 1

    The customer disputes the charge

    They contact their bank and claim a problem with the transaction.[2]

  2. 2

    The bank opens the chargeback

    The disputed amount and a chargeback fee are withdrawn from your account.[2]

  3. 3

    Shopify notifies you

    You get an alert with a deadline to respond. If the issuer claim is available, read it to see why the dispute was opened.[2]

  4. 4

    You gather and submit evidence

    You have limited time, usually 7–21 days. Some chargebacks are accepted automatically when the details show a very low chance of winning and you do not respond by the deadline.[2]

  5. 5

    The card company reviews it

    This can take up to 75 days after you submit.[2]

  6. 6

    A decision is made

    If you win, the disputed amount and fee are returned. A partial win returns some of the amount. If the customer wins, you keep nothing.[2]

Shopify does not decide chargeback outcomes. The customer's bank and card company decide based on your evidence, there is no appeal after they rule, and Shopify cannot overturn the decision.[2] That makes the first response the one that counts.

What to submit for each of the seven dispute types

Shopify sorts chargebacks into seven categories, and the evidence that helps differs for each.[2]

  • Fraudulent transaction (the cardholder says they did not authorise it): AVS and CVV match results, device and IP data consistent with earlier orders, 3D Secure authentication if it was completed, previous undisputed orders from the same customer, delivery confirmation and any messages where the customer acknowledged the order.[2]
  • Product not received: for physical products, the carrier name, tracking number and delivery status, proof of delivery (ideally a signature or photo), proof it went to the checkout address, and carrier notifications sent to the customer.[2]
  • Product unacceptable (defective, damaged, counterfeit or not as described): your product listing as it was at the time of purchase, your return policy and your messages with the customer.[2]
  • Credit not processed: the refund transaction record with timestamp, amount and confirmation number, your refund policy as agreed at checkout, return tracking and your messages about the refund.[2]
  • Duplicate charge: transaction logs showing one charge, or showing separate orders, with order numbers, timestamps and items compared, plus proof of any refund already issued.[2]
  • Subscription canceled: the subscription agreement the customer accepted, including billing cycle and auto-renewal, and records of the cancellation status.[2]
  • General (amount, currency or processing disputes): an itemised receipt, the checkout total shown before payment, your pricing policy, and the exchange rate used for international transactions.[2]

If you really do owe the customer a refund, Shopify suggests issuing it from your admin. You might still lose the chargeback, but it shows good service and can prevent future disputes.[2]

What Shopify Payments sends for you

With Shopify Payments, order information from your admin is added to your response automatically, and the response is submitted on the due date even if you add nothing yourself.[2] When it is available, that includes:

  • Product, customer, billing and shipping details, and the IP address used to place the order.[2]
  • Fulfilment details and a tracking PDF for orders with a tracking number, which for some carriers includes the delivery photo.[2]
  • Refund records, including the acquirer reference number (ARN) the bank can use to trace each refund.[2]
  • The customer's earlier undisputed orders and any earlier disputes with your store.[2]
  • CVV and AVS results and the authorisation code, and 3D Secure details for fraud disputes when they support your case.[2]

That automatic evidence comes only from your Shopify admin. Shopify recommends adding what only you have: emails and chat logs with the customer, the policies that apply and where the customer agreed to them, a carrier delivery photo or signature not already in the tracking PDF, access logs for digital products, and your product listings from the time of purchase. Proof of delivery is strong evidence, so add it when you have it.[2]

If the customer went to their bank without contacting you first, include evidence that no support request was received, your contact details and resolution process, and a note that you would have resolved the issue.[2]

What evidence cannot guarantee

Strong evidence improves your chances but does not guarantee a win. Banks can rule for the customer even when you provide delivery confirmation or other compelling proof.[2] Chargebacks also count against your store: a high chargeback rate can affect your Shopify Payments status and eligibility for features such as the Shop app, and you can monitor that rate in your admin.[2]

So the cheapest chargeback is the one that never opens. Shopify points out that when its fraud analysis reports an order as high risk, you can review it and choose to cancel it, which can help you avoid chargebacks on fraudulent transactions.[1] The guides on Shopify high-risk orders and chargeback prevention cover that side.

Where a hold app fits

Fraudulent-transaction disputes often start with an order that looked wrong before it shipped. Estre, which we make, checks each new Shopify order, adds its reasons to the order, and can hold a high-risk order until you approve it (it ships) or block it (it is cancelled, refunded and restocked). You can start in Watch mode, which records what Estre would do without changing anything. There is a free plan.[3]

Questions

How long do I have to respond to a Shopify chargeback?
Usually 7–21 days. Shopify alerts you with the exact deadline when the chargeback opens. Some chargebacks are accepted automatically if you do not respond by the deadline and the details show a very low chance of winning.[2]
Does Shopify decide who wins a chargeback?
No. The customer's bank and card company decide based on the evidence you submit. After they rule there is no appeal, and Shopify cannot overturn the decision.[2]
Do I get the chargeback fee back if I win?
Shopify's chargeback process says that if a chargeback is resolved in your favour, the disputed amount and the chargeback fee are returned. Its overview adds that fee refunds can depend on your country or region.[1][2]
How long does a chargeback decision take?
The card company's review can take up to 75 days after you submit. Inquiries usually take 65–75 days but might take longer.[2]
What is the best evidence for a fraud chargeback on Shopify?
Shopify names matching addresses, consistent device or location data, and delivery confirmation to the billing address as the strongest evidence, alongside AVS and CVV results and 3D Secure authentication when the customer completed it.[2]

Hold risky orders before they ship

Estre checks each new Shopify order as it arrives and can hold high-risk ones until you approve or block them, with its reasons on the order. There is a free plan, and Watch mode lets you see what it would do first.

Disclosure: Estre is made by Misimi Corp, which also makes Shaewoo and publishes this site.

Sources

Every fact in this guide links to one of these, read on 19 November 2026. Estre is named only where it is relevant; nothing here is a review, a rating or a promise about results.

  1. Shopify Help Center: Chargebacks and inquiries
  2. Shopify Help Center: Responding to chargebacks and inquiries
  3. Shopify App Store: Estre listing